Insurance agencies are priced on three different measures, and the one in use depends mostly on size. Agencies with about $1M or more of EBITDA are priced on EBITDA by aggregators, private equity backed brokers and other agencies. Smaller agencies are often priced on commission and fee revenue, because the book of renewals is the asset and revenue is the cleanest way to count it. Agencies sold through business brokers on Main Street are usually priced on seller's discretionary earnings (SDE), which adds the owner's pay and perks back into profit.

Anyone reading an insurance multiple also has to ask whether it is the upfront price or the total including an earnout. Insurance deals use earnouts heavily, and the gap between the two can be several turns. The guide to how buyers value a small business covers the earnings measures.

What the published insurance multiples show

Seven figures from three publishers are on file.

  • MarshBerry, through an article by its Phil Trem in Leader's Edge (31 Mar 2026), reports that brokerage deals in the twelve months to Q4 2025 averaged 11.50x EBITDA on the upfront base price and up to 15.48x with the maximum earnout. Platform firms, the large agencies a buyer uses as its base, averaged 14.34x upfront and up to 18.41x.
  • Sofer Advisors (March 2026) gives 6x to 12x EBITDA for agencies with $1M or more of EBITDA, with most deals between 7x and 10x. For agencies under $5M of revenue it gives 1.0x to 3.0x commission and fee income, with most quality agencies between 1.5x and 2.5x.
  • BizBuySell recorded 50 agency sales in 2025 at an average 2.68x SDE and 1.53x revenue, with a median sale price of $650,000. Its benchmark page for 2021 to 2025 says half of agencies sold between 1.88x and 3.44x SDE.

Published multiples for insurance agencies

Low to high, by metric and size band as each source publishes them

EBITDA, all firms, upfront base priceLeader's Edge, Brokerage M&A Holds Firm in Volatile Economy (Phil Trem, MarshBerry data), 31 Mar 2026
EBITDA, all firms, including maximum earnoutLeader's Edge, Brokerage M&A Holds Firm in Volatile Economy (Phil Trem, MarshBerry data), 31 Mar 2026
EBITDA, platform firms, upfront base priceLeader's Edge, Brokerage M&A Holds Firm in Volatile Economy (Phil Trem, MarshBerry data), 31 Mar 2026
EBITDA, agencies with $1M+ EBITDASofer Advisors, How to Value an Insurance Agency: Multiples and Methods, Mar 2026
revenue, agencies under $5M revenue (commission and fee income)Sofer Advisors, How to Value an Insurance Agency: Multiples and Methods, Mar 2026
SDE, all reported sales (median sale price $650,000)BizBuySell Insight Report data tables, full-year 2025 by sector, undated page; FY2025 data (read 2026-11-18)
SDE, middle half of sales 2021-2025BizBuySell, Insurance Agency valuation benchmarks, 2026
0x5x10x15x
Sources: Leader's Edge, Brokerage M&A Holds Firm in Volatile Economy (Phil Trem, MarshBerry data), 31 Mar 2026; Sofer Advisors, How to Value an Insurance Agency: Multiples and Methods, Mar 2026; BizBuySell Insight Report data tables, full-year 2025 by sector, undated page; FY2025 data (read 2026-11-18); BizBuySell, Insurance Agency valuation benchmarks, 2026

Why the insurance ranges differ

Who is in the sample. The MarshBerry figures cover brokerage deals it tracks, and they skew toward larger agencies. They are averages, so a few large deals pull them up. BizBuySell's 50 sales are small agencies sold through business brokers. The two describe different markets.

Upfront against total. The MarshBerry averages are published both ways. A seller comparing an offer with 11.50x should check whether the offer's figure includes the earnout. Comparing an upfront offer with a total-value benchmark makes the offer look about four turns low.

Revenue against earnings. Sofer's revenue range and BizBuySell's revenue average agree closely: 1.53x sits inside Sofer's 1.5x to 2.5x band for quality agencies. EBITDA multiples look far higher because EBITDA is a fraction of revenue.

Guidance against deal data. Sofer's ranges are valuation-firm guidance with no deal count. MarshBerry's own quarterly data is not on its public pages, so the figures here come from the trade press article. MarshBerry's 2022 explainer described multiples running from the "mid-single digits to the mid-teens," which covers most of both sources' ranges.

What moves an insurance agency multiple

Factor Why buyers care
Size, growth and profitability MarshBerry says firms that command higher than average multiples tend to be larger, growing fast and steadily profitable. Its 2022 explainer put top independent firms at 25% to 30% or more EBITDA margin, against an estimated 15% to 20% on average.
Book retention Sofer says the retention rate sets where an agency lands in the revenue range. Renewals that stay are the revenue a buyer is paying for.
Carrier concentration Sofer counts carrier concentration among the same factors. An agency that leans on one carrier depends on that relationship holding.
Line-of-business mix Sofer lists line-of-business mix among the factors that set the revenue multiple.
Earnout targets The MarshBerry figures put the maximum total about four turns above the upfront multiple when growth targets are met.

The insurance agency buyers page lists aggregators and brokers with the criteria they publish.

A worked example on a published range

At the 1.0x to 3.0x range Sofer Advisors publishes for agencies under $5M of revenue, $1.2M of commission and fee income implies $1.2M to $3.6M. At MarshBerry's averages, $2M of EBITDA implies $23M upfront at 11.50x and up to $30.96M at 15.48x if every earnout target is met. These are arithmetic on published figures, shown as an illustration. They do not value any agency.

Headline price and value received

The second illustration shows why the headline needs a closer read. Of the $30.96M, $7.96M is contingent, and an earnout pays only what the targets allow. SRS Acquiom's 2026 study, covering private deals where it provided services, found 24% of 2025 deals outside life sciences carried an earnout and a median earnout length of 21 months.

Cash at closing also differs from the upfront price once escrow and any seller note are counted. Across all industries, the IBBA's Q2 2026 survey found sellers received 83% to 92% in cash at close on average. The guide to earnouts and seller notes covers how targets are set and measured, and the quality of earnings guide covers how buyers test the EBITDA. With an offer in hand, the offer check shows the multiple it implies and the share paid at closing, and the guide to judging an offer lists the terms to read first.

To apply the published insurance ranges to your own revenue or earnings, open the private range tool.

Turn these multiples into a price range. Open the private range tool. It runs in your browser and stores nothing you type.

Every published multiple across industries is on the valuation multiples page.

Questions owners ask

How is an insurance agency valued?

Agencies with about $1M or more of EBITDA are priced on EBITDA. Smaller agencies are often priced on commission and fee revenue, at 1.0x to 3.0x in Sofer Advisors' guidance, or on SDE when sold through a business broker.

What multiple do buyers pay for an insurance agency?

MarshBerry data reported by Leader's Edge shows an average 11.50x EBITDA upfront for brokerage deals in the year to Q4 2025, a population that skews to larger agencies. BizBuySell's 2025 tables show an average 2.68x SDE across 50 smaller agency sales.

Why do insurance agency deals include earnouts?

Buyers pay part of the price only if the book grows or holds after closing. In the MarshBerry figures the maximum earnout lifted the average from 11.50x to 15.48x EBITDA, about four turns.

How long does it take to sell an insurance agency?

BizBuySell's 2025 tables show a median of 184 days on market for reported agency sales. The IBBA's Q2 2026 survey puts engagement to close at 6 to 12 months across industries.

Sources
  1. Leader's Edge, Brokerage M&A Holds Firm in Volatile Economy (Phil Trem, MarshBerry data), 2026-03-31. https://www.leadersedge.com/industry/brokerage-ma-holds-firm-in-volatile-economy
  2. Sofer Advisors, How to Value an Insurance Agency: Multiples and Methods, 2026-03. https://soferadvisors.com/insights/blog/how-to-value-an-insurance-agency-multiples-and-methods/
  3. BizBuySell Insight Report data tables, full-year 2025 by sector, undated page; FY2025 data (read 2026-11-18). https://www.bizbuysell.com/insight-report-data-tables/
  4. BizBuySell, Insurance Agency valuation benchmarks, 2026. https://www.bizbuysell.com/learning-center/valuation-benchmarks/insurance-agency/
  5. MarshBerry, How to Calculate Your Insurance Firm's Value, 2022-04-06. https://www.marshberry.com/resource/how-to-think-about-value/
  6. SRS Acquiom, 2026 M&A Deal Terms Study, 2026. https://learn.srsacquiom.com/rs/664-KLJ-520/images/SRSAcquiom-2026-Deal-Terms-Study.pdf
  7. IBBA and M&A Source, Market Pulse Q2 2026 Executive Summary, 2026-08. https://www.ibba.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/mp-executive-courtesy-q2-2026.pdf