Who buys insurance agencies today
Several kinds of buyer make offers for independent insurance agencies. Private equity backed brokers, often called aggregators, buy agencies to add premium and producers. OPTIS Partners, which tracks announced deals, counts hybrid brokers in the same group. Privately held brokers and publicly traded brokers buy too, and so do other independent agencies.
OPTIS counted 695 insurance agency transactions in the US and Canada in 2025, down from 787 in 2024, as reported by Insurance Journal. Through the third quarter of 2025, private equity backed and hybrid buyers made 72% of all acquisitions, according to OPTIS data reported by Insurance Business. Publicly held brokers did 27% fewer deals in 2025 than the year before. Agencies sold through brokers on BizBuySell spent a median 184 days on the market in 2025.
Our guide to who buys small businesses compares these buyer types across industries.
Insurance buyers with published criteria
Four buyers of insurance agencies in our records publish criteria. The profiles below are drafted from each buyer's public pages, with the page and the date we read it. Only one publishes a size band, and it starts at $5 million of EBITDA, so it applies only to large agencies.
Lovell Minnick Partners lists insurance distribution among its subsectors at $5 million to $30 million of EBITDA. Keystone Agency Partners writes that it seeks legacy led, high performing agencies with a strong growth record. Leavitt Group describes a co-ownership model in which the local agency manager keeps significant equity and keeps running the agency. Inszone Insurance Services, whose private equity partner is Lightyear Capital, writes that most of its acquisitions are cash deals with a possible equity component, and that sellers who stay can align through equity and earnouts.
- Industries
- Wealth manager, Insurance agency, Accounting firm
- EBITDA
- $5M to $30M
- Industries
- Insurance agency
- Structure
- Acquisition as a Platform Partner
- Industries
- Insurance agency
- Structure
- Co-ownership: the local agency manager keeps significant equity, Sale or other ownership transition at retirement
- Industries
- Insurance agency
- Structure
- Mostly cash deals, with a possible equity component, Equity and earnouts for sellers who stay
Each profile is drafted from the buyer's own published criteria, with the source and the date we read it. Filter by your size and state.
To filter buyers by state and size, open the buyer match tool.
Private equity firms that hold insurance brokers
PE Firm Index reads each private equity firm's own portfolio page. On those reads, nine firms hold insurance agencies or brokers today, with 11 holdings between them. The table shows all nine.
Private equity firms that hold insurance agencies today
Each row is read from the firm's own portfolio page.
| Firm | Holdings | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| CIVC Partners | 2 | Crest Insurance Group, StoneRidge Insurance Brokers |
| Stone Point Capital | 2 | Alliant Insurance Services, Private Client Select Insurance Services |
| Corsair Capital | 1 | Oakbridge Insurance Agency |
| FTV Capital | 1 | Arden Insurance Services |
| GI Partners | 1 | Patriot Growth Insurance Services |
| Huron Capital | 1 | Highstreet Insurance Partners |
| Lindsay Goldberg | 1 | Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. |
| Lovell Minnick Partners | 1 | Warner Pacific Insurance Services |
| Summit Partners | 1 | Patriot Growth Insurance Services |
Two firms hold two each: CIVC Partners (Crest Insurance Group and StoneRidge Insurance Brokers) and Stone Point Capital (Alliant Insurance Services and Private Client Select Insurance Services). Two brokers are listed by more than one firm. Alliant appears under Stone Point and Lindsay Goldberg, and Patriot Growth Insurance Services under GI Partners and Summit Partners. Lovell Minnick Partners, one of the buyers with a published profile above, holds Warner Pacific Insurance Services.
Recent insurance deals on file
Our deal records hold three dated insurance transactions from the last three months. BayPine backed Relation Insurance Services bought Wright Insurance Planning in November 2026. Mill Point Capital backed Franklin Madison bought Bindable, a digital distribution platform and property and casualty agency, in October 2026. Equal Parts bought ProSource Insurance Agency in September 2026.
Recent insurance agency deals on file
| Date | Buyer | Company bought | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Nov 2026 | Relation Insurance Services backed by BayPine | Wright Insurance Planning | linkedin.com |
| 28 Oct 2026 | Franklin Madison backed by Mill Point Capital | Bindable | millpoint.com |
| 18 Sep 2026 | Equal Parts | ProSource Insurance Agency | businesswire.com |
How insurance agency buyers pay
Earnouts are more common in agency deals than in private company sales overall. SRS Acquiom found an earnout in 24% of the private deals it serviced in 2025. Reagan Consulting, which surveys active acquirers, reports in IA Magazine that earnouts are a feature in the majority of agency transactions. They represent about 25% to 35% of overall value and last three to four years after closing on average. Half of sellers maximized their earnouts over the three years the survey covered. Sellers with EBITDA based earnouts maxed them out almost two thirds of the time, against just over a third for revenue based ones.
| Buyer type | How the price is usually paid | Source |
|---|---|---|
| All tracked brokerage buyers | Upfront base price averaging 11.5 times EBITDA | MarshBerry via Leader's Edge, 2026 |
| All tracked brokerage buyers | Up to 15.48 times EBITDA if the maximum earnout is paid | MarshBerry via Leader's Edge, 2026 |
| Platform acquisitions | Upfront base price averaging 14.34 times EBITDA | MarshBerry via Leader's Edge, 2026 |
| Active acquirers | Earnout worth about 25% to 35% of overall value, three to four years | Reagan Consulting, 2024 |
| Inszone | Mostly cash, with possible equity, and earnouts for sellers who stay | Inszone |
| Leavitt Group | Local manager keeps significant equity as co-owner | Leavitt Group |
| Any buyer, all industries, deals of $1M to $5M | 84% to 91% cash at closing on average, 7% to 9% seller financing | IBBA Market Pulse, Q2 2026 |
The MarshBerry figures cover deals it tracks, which skew toward larger agencies. MarshBerry names size, growth and steady profitability as the traits that earn above average multiples, and Sofer Advisors adds that book retention, carrier concentration and the mix of business lines set where an agency lands within the published revenue range. The gap between 11.5 and 15.48 times is the earnout, paid only if growth targets are met. Our guide to earnouts and seller notes explains how targets are set and measured, and selling to private equity covers the equity piece. Published multiples by size sit on the insurance valuation page.
Before you compare insurance agency offers
Two agency offers with the same headline multiple can differ by a quarter or more of their value in what is guaranteed at closing once the earnout is split out. The offer check shows the multiple an offer implies and how much of it arrives on day one.
Have an offer already? Run the offer check to see the multiple it implies and how much of it you receive at closing.
Questions owners ask
Who buys insurance agencies?
Private equity backed and hybrid brokers, privately held brokers, publicly traded brokers and other agencies. OPTIS Partners data reported by Insurance Business shows private equity backed and hybrid buyers made 72% of announced agency acquisitions through the third quarter of 2025.
How is the sale of an insurance agency usually paid?
Mostly in cash at closing with an earnout on top. Reagan Consulting reports that earnouts appear in the majority of agency deals, are worth about 25% to 35% of overall value and last three to four years on average.
How is an insurance agency valued?
Larger agencies are priced on EBITDA and smaller ones often on revenue or seller's discretionary earnings. MarshBerry data reported by Leader's Edge puts the average upfront price at 11.5 times EBITDA; our insurance valuation page lists every published range.
How many insurance agencies sold in 2025?
OPTIS Partners counted 695 announced insurance agency deals in the US and Canada in 2025, down from 787 in 2024, as reported by Insurance Journal.
- Insurance Journal, Pace of Insurance M&A Lagged in 2025 With No Mad Dash (OPTIS Partners data), 2026-01. https://amp.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2026/01/22/855124.htm
- Insurance Business, Insurance agency M&A slows in 2025 (OPTIS Partners data), 2025-10. https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/mergers-acquisitions/insurance-agency-manda-slows-in-2025--optis-553734.aspx
- BizBuySell Insight Report data tables, full-year 2025 by sector, 2026-11. https://www.bizbuysell.com/insight-report-data-tables/
- Lovell Minnick Partners, Focus, 2026-11. https://www.lovellminnick.com/focus/
- Keystone Agency Partners, Platform partners, 2026-11. https://mykeystone.com/platform-partners/
- Leavitt Group, Partnership, 2026-11. https://www.leavitt.com/affiliation/partnership
- Inszone Insurance Services, Mergers and acquisitions, 2026-11. https://inszoneinsurance.com/mergers-and-acquisitions
- PE Firm Index, private equity portfolio reads, 2026-11. https://pefirmindex.com
- Mill Point Capital, Franklin Madison acquires Bindable, 2026-10. https://millpoint.com/franklin-madison-acquires-bindable-digital-distribution-platform-and-pc-agency/
- Business Wire, Equal Parts Acquires ProSource Insurance Agency, 2026-09. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260918939629/en/Equal-Parts-Acquires-ProSource-Insurance-Agency-Expanding-Transportation-Insurance-Platform
- Leader's Edge, Brokerage M&A Holds Firm in Volatile Economy (MarshBerry data), 2026-03. https://www.leadersedge.com/industry/brokerage-ma-holds-firm-in-volatile-economy
- MarshBerry, How to think about value, 2026-11. https://www.marshberry.com/resource/how-to-think-about-value/
- Sofer Advisors, How to Value an Insurance Agency: Multiples and Methods, 2026-03. https://soferadvisors.com/insights/blog/how-to-value-an-insurance-agency-multiples-and-methods/
- IA Magazine, Earn-Out Evolution: How Have Sellers Performed Post-Closing? (Reagan Consulting), 2024-08. https://www.iamagazine.com/news/earn-out-evolution-how-have-sellers-performed-post-closing/
- SRS Acquiom, 2026 M&A Deal Terms Study, 2026. https://learn.srsacquiom.com/rs/664-KLJ-520/images/SRSAcquiom-2026-Deal-Terms-Study.pdf
- IBBA and M&A Source, Market Pulse Q2 2026 Executive Summary, 2026-08. https://www.ibba.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/mp-executive-courtesy-q2-2026.pdf