Independent insurance agencies sell into an active buyer market. OPTIS Partners counted 695 agency transactions in the US and Canada in 2025, as reported by Insurance Journal, and through the third quarter of 2025 private equity backed and hybrid brokers made 72% of acquisitions, according to OPTIS data reported by Insurance Business. The process is familiar. What differs is the cast of outside parties: carriers, producers and the clients whose renewals make up the price.
What an insurance agency buyer checks first
Buyers start with the book. Sofer Advisors writes that retention, carrier concentration and the mix of business lines set where an agency lands within the published revenue range. MarshBerry writes that agencies earning above average multiples tend to be larger, growing fast and steadily profitable, and its 2022 explainer put top independent firms at 25% to 30% or more EBITDA margin against an estimated 15% to 20% on average.
What can leave on a leak sits in the same places. A producer who controls key accounts can move them, a carrier with a change of ownership clause can act on it, and clients who hear rumors at renewal can shop their coverage. An IA Magazine article from the Big I calls the agency's ownership of its expirations "the cornerstone of the independent agency system."
The insurance agency sale in nine steps
- Prepare the numbers. Commission and fee revenue by carrier, line and producer, retention, contingent income and owner pay. The 12-month exit planning guide lists the work.
- Get a range. Larger agencies price on EBITDA, smaller ones on commission and fee revenue or SDE. The insurance valuation page lists each range, and the business valuation calculator applies them to your figure.
- Read every carrier agreement. Note the change of ownership, notice, termination and expiration clauses before any buyer is contacted.
- Shortlist buyers. Aggregators, privately held and public brokers, and other agencies.
- Share a blind profile. Revenue in a band, line mix, region and retention in broad terms.
- Sign an NDA. It should bar soliciting producers, staff and clients.
- Compare letters of intent. Upfront price, earnout targets and any equity in the buyer. The letter of intent guide covers each clause.
- Diligence and closing. Producer agreements, carrier statements, errors and omissions history and licensing.
- Transition. Carrier notices and appointments, producer agreements with the buyer and client letters.
Where confidentiality has to end with carriers
The carrier agreements set the point. In IA Magazine, published by the Big I, Scott Kneeland and Eric Lipton write that a requirement to give a carrier advance notice of a change in ownership can be problematic because it may violate the NDA with the buyer. They argue that an agency-carrier agreement should not terminate immediately on a change in ownership, and that a notice clause should apply only to changes in a majority or controlling interest. The same article recommends that the carrier affirmatively recognize the agency's ownership of its expirations and records.
So the order of disclosure is set by contract. An owner who reads each agreement early knows which carriers must hear before closing and which after. When producers hear is the owner's call, and the confidential sale guide covers the timing for key people and the staged release of everything else.
Who sells insurance agencies
Larger agencies can hire specialist investment banks and consultants, including firms that publish market data cited here, such as MarshBerry, Reagan Consulting and OPTIS Partners. Smaller agencies sell through business brokers or directly to an aggregator or a local agency. BizBuySell's learning center puts the most common business broker commission at 10% to 15% for businesses sold between $100,000 and $1 million, with a reduced percentage above that. Axial's 2026 survey of 331 M&A advisors found 71% charge some form of upfront fee. The broker or M&A advisor guide covers the other terms.
Timelines and terms in agency deals
BizBuySell's 2025 data shows a median 184 days on market for agencies sold through brokers. Earnouts are the defining term. Reagan Consulting reports in IA Magazine that they appear in the majority of agency deals, are worth about 25% to 35% of overall value and last three to four years on average. MarshBerry data reported by Leader's Edge puts the average upfront price at 11.5 times EBITDA, rising to 15.48 times if every earnout target is met. Inszone writes that most of its deals are cash with a possible equity component, and Leavitt Group describes a model in which the local manager keeps significant equity.
Insurance buyers with published criteria
The insurance agency buyers page covers every type of buyer and how each one pays. Four buyers of insurance agencies in our records publish criteria: Lovell Minnick Partners, Keystone Agency Partners, Leavitt Group and Inszone Insurance Services. Only one publishes a size band.
- Industries
- Wealth manager, Insurance agency, Accounting firm
- EBITDA
- $5M to $30M
- Industries
- Insurance agency
- Structure
- Acquisition as a Platform Partner
- Industries
- Insurance agency
- Structure
- Co-ownership: the local agency manager keeps significant equity, Sale or other ownership transition at retirement
- Industries
- Insurance agency
- Structure
- Mostly cash deals, with a possible equity component, Equity and earnouts for sellers who stay
Each profile is drafted from the buyer's own published criteria, with the source and the date we read it. Filter by your size and state.
Before you compare agency offers
Two agency offers at the same headline multiple can differ by a quarter or more of their value in what is guaranteed at closing once the earnout is split out. The offer check shows the multiple an offer implies and how much of it arrives on day one.
Have an offer already? Run the offer check to see the multiple it implies and how much of it you receive at closing.
Questions owners ask
How do I sell my insurance agency?
Owners usually prepare three years of financials and commission revenue by carrier and line, get a range from published multiples, shortlist aggregators and other agencies, share a blind profile, sign NDAs, compare letters of intent, then work through diligence, carrier notices, closing and the client transition.
Do I have to tell my carriers before I sell my agency?
It depends on each agency agreement. An IA Magazine article from the Big I warns that a clause requiring advance notice of a change in ownership can conflict with the NDA signed with a buyer, and that an agreement should not terminate immediately on a change in ownership.
How common are earnouts in insurance agency sales?
Reagan Consulting reports in IA Magazine that earnouts feature in the majority of agency deals, worth about 25% to 35% of overall value and lasting three to four years on average.
How long does it take to sell an insurance agency?
BizBuySell's 2025 data shows a median 184 days on market for agencies sold through brokers. The IBBA's Q2 2026 survey put Main Street deals at six to 10 months from engagement to close.
- MarshBerry, How to think about value, 2022-04-06. https://www.marshberry.com/resource/how-to-think-about-value/
- Sofer Advisors, How to Value an Insurance Agency: Multiples and Methods, 2026-03. https://soferadvisors.com/insights/blog/how-to-value-an-insurance-agency-multiples-and-methods/
- IA Magazine, Scott Kneeland and Eric Lipton, 9 Considerations for Agency-Company Appointment Contracts, 2023-03-01 (read 2026-11-20). https://www.iamagazine.com/?p=7001
- IA Magazine, Earn-Out Evolution: How Have Sellers Performed Post-Closing? (Reagan Consulting), 2024-08. https://www.iamagazine.com/news/earn-out-evolution-how-have-sellers-performed-post-closing/
- Leader's Edge, Brokerage M&A Holds Firm in Volatile Economy (MarshBerry data), 2026-03-31. https://www.leadersedge.com/industry/brokerage-ma-holds-firm-in-volatile-economy
- Insurance Journal, Pace of Insurance M&A Lagged in 2025 With No Mad Dash (OPTIS Partners data), 2026-01. https://amp.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2026/01/22/855124.htm
- Insurance Business, Insurance agency M&A slows in 2025 (OPTIS Partners data), 2025-10. https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/mergers-acquisitions/insurance-agency-manda-slows-in-2025--optis-553734.aspx
- Inszone Insurance Services, Mergers and acquisitions, 2026-11. https://inszoneinsurance.com/mergers-and-acquisitions
- Leavitt Group, Partnership, 2026-11. https://www.leavitt.com/affiliation/partnership
- BizBuySell Insight Report data tables, full-year 2025 by sector, 2026-11. https://www.bizbuysell.com/insight-report-data-tables/
- BizBuySell Learning Center, To Pay or Not to Pay, Business Broker Fees, read 2026-11-20. https://www.bizbuysell.com/learning-center/article/business-broker-fees/
- Axial, 2026 M&A Fee Guide, 2026-06-23. https://www.axial.net/forum/ma-fee-guide-2025-2026/
- IBBA and M&A Source, The Market Pulse Survey Q2 2026 Reports the Latest Trends in Business Sales up to $50M (PR Newswire), 2026-08-25. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/the-market-pulse-survey-q2-2026-reports-the-latest-trends-in-business-sales-up-to-50m-302858664.html
